73 Would You Rather Questions For High School Teachers

Alright, imagine you're a superhero, but instead of capes and superpowers, your tools are grading pens and lesson plans. That's kind of what being a high school teacher is like! And just like any superhero needs to think on their feet, teachers often face tricky situations. That's where Would You Rather Questions For High School Teachers come in. They're a fun way to explore those "what if" moments and get everyone thinking about the awesome, and sometimes wild, world of education.

What Are Would You Rather Questions For High School Teachers?

So, what exactly are these "Would You Rather Questions For High School Teachers"? Think of them as mini-dilemmas. Someone gives you two options, and you have to pick one, even if both choices seem a little… out there. They’re like a game of "choose your own adventure" for educators. They're super popular because they’re not just about silly choices, but they can also make us think about the real challenges and joys of teaching. Plus, they’re a fantastic icebreaker or a way to liven up a staff meeting!

Here’s why they’re so great:

They spark conversations.
They encourage creative problem-solving.
They can reveal different perspectives.
They make light of stressful situations.

Teachers use these questions in all sorts of ways. Sometimes it’s just for a laugh during a tough grading session. Other times, a well-placed question can lead to a really important discussion about teaching strategies or classroom management. The importance of these questions lies in their ability to foster empathy and understanding among colleagues , showing that everyone faces unique challenges in the classroom.

Would You Rather: Classroom Quirks

Here are 20 Would You Rather Questions For High School Teachers related to funny or weird classroom situations:

Would you rather have every student accidentally wear the same color shirt every day for a month, or have one student who randomly bursts into song during every lesson?
Would you rather discover your students have secretly been communicating through interpretive dance, or find out they've created a detailed conspiracy theory about the cafeteria food?
Would you rather have your whiteboard permanently covered in glitter that reappears no matter how much you clean it, or have every piece of paper in your classroom magically turn into origami animals at the end of the day?
Would you rather your students only speak in Shakespearean insults, or have them respond to every question with a dramatic reenactment?
Would you rather find a nest of very polite squirrels in your classroom, or have a friendly ghost who keeps rearranging your desk?
Would you rather every student’s backpack contain a rubber chicken, or have every stapler in the school make a loud quack sound when used?
Would you rather have your projector only display vintage cartoons, or have your computer keyboard randomly type out limericks?
Would you rather your students communicate solely through charades, or have them only answer questions in riddles?
Would you rather have a student who thinks they're a cat and occasionally hisses at you, or a student who believes they're a time traveler and keeps giving you cryptic warnings about the future?
Would you rather your entire class spontaneously starts breakdancing when the bell rings, or have a substitute teacher who is a talking parrot?
Would you rather every student’s homework assignment be written in invisible ink that only appears under a blacklight, or have to grade papers that are all written in bubble letters?
Would you rather have a student who communicates exclusively through opera singing, or have a student who only responds by quoting movie lines?
Would you rather your classroom be visited by a flock of very enthusiastic, but slightly destructive, miniature dragons, or have a perpetually singing rubber duck that follows you around?
Would you rather have your grading system be based on a complex game of rock-paper-scissors, or have your lesson plans be dictated by a magic 8-ball?
Would you rather have all your students start communicating in emojis, or have them exclusively use dad jokes as their responses?
Would you rather find out your classroom pet has started a secret society, or have your projector only show silent films of educational content?
Would you rather have your students conduct all debates using puppet shows, or have to grade essays written entirely in haiku?
Would you rather have every student’s backpack contain a tiny disco ball that lights up at random intervals, or have your lesson plans magically swap places with your grocery list each morning?
Would you rather have your students communicate solely through interpretive dance, or have them respond to every question with a dramatic monologue?
Would you rather your classroom be filled with a constant, faint scent of popcorn, or have your textbooks randomly start telling jokes?

Would You Rather: Teaching Dilemmas

Here are 20 Would You Rather Questions For High School Teachers focused on difficult teaching choices:

Would you rather have to teach the same lesson plan for a whole year, or have to create a completely new, complex lesson plan every single day?
Would you rather have students who are brilliant but never participate, or students who participate constantly but rarely grasp the material?
Would you rather have to give every student a perfect score, or have to fail every student?
Would you rather have a class that’s completely silent and disengaged, or a class that’s chaotic and constantly off-topic?
Would you rather have to grade all your papers by hand for a month, or have your grading software malfunction and lose all your digital grades?
Would you rather have parents who hover and question every grade, or parents who never respond to any communication?
Would you rather have your most challenging student suddenly become your star pupil, but only when you’re not looking, or have your star pupil consistently underperform when you are present?
Would you rather have to explain a complex concept using only interpretive dance, or have to write a 500-page essay on a topic you know nothing about?
Would you rather have your lesson plans be constantly interrupted by fire drills, or have your projector bulb burn out every single class period?
Would you rather have students who cheat on every assignment, or students who refuse to do any work at all?
Would you rather have to wear a silly costume every day for a month, or have to sing your lessons like a musical every day for a month?
Would you rather have students who ask brilliant, unanswerable questions constantly, or students who ask questions that have already been answered multiple times?
Would you rather have to grade essays written in crayon, or essays written in a font so small you need a magnifying glass to read it?
Would you rather have a student who constantly tries to befriend you inappropriately, or a student who openly resents you for no reason?
Would you rather have your entire gradebook replaced with a recipe book, or have all your lesson materials turn into confetti?
Would you rather have to teach a subject you absolutely detest, or have to teach the same subject you love, but to a group of students who are actively hostile to it?
Would you rather have your students believe everything you say, even if it's wrong, or have your students constantly question every single thing you say, even if it's right?
Would you rather have your most valuable teaching resource (like a favorite book or tool) stolen, or have your entire lesson plan for the year accidentally deleted?
Would you rather have to apologize to every student for a mistake you made, or have to praise every student for something they didn't do?
Would you rather have your students communicate all their needs and concerns through interpretive dance, or have them submit all their work in the form of a rap song?

Would You Rather: Technology Troubles

Here are 20 Would You Rather Questions For High School Teachers about technology gone wrong:

Would you rather have your smartboard constantly freeze on embarrassing memes, or have your projector only work when you're not in the room?
Would you rather have every student’s device automatically play loud music during your lesson, or have your computer constantly auto-correct words into nonsensical phrases?
Would you rather have your online grading system glitch and randomly assign everyone 100% or 0%, or have your classroom Wi-Fi only work for students playing games?
Would you rather have your email automatically send all your private thoughts to the entire school staff, or have your search history broadcast on the classroom projector?
Would you rather have your students collaborate on projects using only ancient fax machines, or have to submit all your lesson plans on stone tablets?
Would you rather have your learning management system update itself to a completely unrecognizable interface overnight, or have all your digital files turn into tiny animated GIFs?
Would you rather have your microphone only pick up whispers, or have your camera only show your forehead?
Would you rather have your students communicate solely through memes, or have to respond to all student emails using only emojis?
Would you rather have your smart speaker in the classroom randomly start playing conspiracy theories, or have your digital whiteboard write out passive-aggressive notes?
Would you rather have your students’ assignments automatically submitted to a public forum for critique, or have your lesson plans randomly appear on their social media feeds?
Would you rather have your entire digital gradebook turn into a giant game of Tetris, or have your computer only respond to commands given in Pig Latin?
Would you rather have your projector display a live feed of squirrels outside the window, or have your smart board display motivational quotes in Comic Sans?
Would you rather have your students communicate their questions through carrier pigeons, or have to grade essays written on scrolls?
Would you rather have your computer only allow you to type in ancient hieroglyphs, or have your printer only print blank pages?
Would you rather have your online quizzes randomly shuffle the correct answers every time, or have your students’ submissions be automatically translated into a language you don’t understand?
Would you rather have your smart watch constantly tell you when you’re being a bad teacher, or have your classroom smart speaker rate your jokes?
Would you rather have your students collaborate on projects using only Morse code, or have to submit all your lesson plans via carrier pigeon?
Would you rather have your video conferencing software automatically add clown noses and hats to everyone’s avatars, or have your microphone produce animal sound effects at random intervals?
Would you rather have your students submit all their work as interpretive dances, or have to grade essays written in invisible ink?
Would you rather have your computer auto-suggest entire paragraphs of nonsensical advice during your typing, or have your smart board display a live countdown to the apocalypse?

Would You Rather: Subject-Specific Shenanigans

Here are 20 Would You Rather Questions For High School Teachers about specific subject areas:

(Math) Would you rather have all your students believe that pi is exactly 3, or have them insist that parallel lines meet at the cafeteria?
(English) Would you rather have your students only speak in iambic pentameter, or have them only communicate through dramatic monologues?
(Science) Would you rather have your students believe that gravity is a personal opinion, or that elements are just made-up stories?
(History) Would you rather have your students believe that historical figures were all secretly spies, or that major wars were fought over who made the best sandwich?
(Art) Would you rather have your students only create art using chewed gum, or have their art supplies replaced with edible items?
(Music) Would you rather have your students only play songs with a single note repeated endlessly, or have them only sing in a language that doesn't exist?
(Foreign Language) Would you rather have your students only learn the curse words in a language, or have them insist on speaking only in archaic dialects?
(Physical Education) Would you rather have your students only participate in synchronized napping, or have all sports replaced by competitive thumb wrestling?
(Computer Science) Would you rather have your students believe that computers run on hamster power, or that code is written using magic spells?
(Biology) Would you rather have your students believe that plants communicate through interpretive dance, or that animals evolve based on fashion trends?
(Chemistry) Would you rather have your students believe that all chemical reactions are caused by emotional outbursts, or that elements are colored based on their mood?
(Physics) Would you rather have your students believe that the speed of light is adjustable with a dimmer switch, or that time travel is only possible via a very fast bicycle?
(Economics) Would you rather have your students believe that money grows on trees, or that supply and demand are determined by popular opinion?
(Psychology) Would you rather have your students believe that all behavior is caused by an invisible cartoon character, or that dreams are literal prophecies?
(Sociology) Would you rather have your students believe that society is secretly run by a committee of garden gnomes, or that social norms are dictated by dance crazes?
(Geography) Would you rather have your students believe that all maps are drawn by birds, or that oceans are just very large puddles?
(Literature) Would you rather have your students interpret all novels as elaborate scavenger hunts, or believe that punctuation is just a stylistic choice?
(Theatre) Would you rather have your students only perform plays where all the dialogue is sung operatically, or have them improvise entire scenes based on random sound effects?
(Philosophy) Would you rather have your students believe that the meaning of life is to find the perfect snack, or that free will is an illusion created by socks disappearing in the laundry?
(Home Economics) Would you rather have your students believe that all recipes are secret government formulas, or that cooking is a form of extreme sport?

Would You Rather: Parent-Teacher Interactions

Here are 20 Would You Rather Questions For High School Teachers about dealing with parents:

Would you rather have parents who call you at 2 AM with trivial questions, or parents who email you daily with essays of concern?
Would you rather have parents who insist their child is a genius and you're holding them back, or parents who believe their child is incapable of any learning?
Would you rather have parents who demand a refund for tuition because their child didn't get an A, or parents who threaten to sue because their child got a B?
Would you rather have to meet with a parent who is constantly interrupting you with their own anecdotes, or a parent who sits in complete silence and just stares?
Would you rather have parents who think their child is a victim of bullying from everyone but them, or parents who think their child is the bully of the entire school?
Would you rather have to explain your grading policy to a parent who speaks only in riddles, or a parent who communicates exclusively through interpretive dance?
Would you rather have parents who send you daily photos of their child’s artwork, or parents who send you daily videos of their child’s questionable life choices?
Would you rather have to defend your curriculum to parents who believe in flat earth theory, or parents who think homework is a government conspiracy?
Would you rather have parents who insist on being in the classroom during every lesson, or parents who try to bribe you with baked goods to change grades?
Would you rather have to deal with parents who think your subject is completely useless, or parents who think your subject is the only one that matters?
Would you rather have parents who create a Facebook group dedicated to complaining about you, or parents who write strongly worded letters to the superintendent daily?
Would you rather have to meet with a parent who insists their child can read your mind, or a parent who believes their child communicates with aliens?
Would you rather have parents who believe all tests are rigged, or parents who believe their child wrote a Nobel Prize-winning essay themselves?
Would you rather have to explain a student’s poor behavior to parents who think it’s a sign of genius, or parents who think it’s a sign of demonic possession?
Would you rather have parents who want to "negotiate" grades, or parents who want to "tutor" you on how to teach?
Would you rather have to deal with parents who believe their child is a prodigy in every subject, or parents who believe their child is a victim of a vast academic conspiracy?
Would you rather have parents who send you daily gifts of questionable origin, or parents who demand you communicate only through carrier pigeon?
Would you rather have to explain complex educational theories to parents who think "education" means memorizing random facts, or parents who think it means practicing pop culture trivia?
Would you rather have parents who believe their child’s every word is gospel, or parents who believe their child is constantly being misunderstood by society?
Would you rather have to field calls from parents who want to discuss their child’s dreams, or parents who want to discuss their child’s alleged psychic abilities?

Would You Rather: End-of-Year Extravaganzas

Here are 20 Would You Rather Questions For High School Teachers about the chaotic end of the school year:

Would you rather have to grade every single final exam by hand in 24 hours, or have your grading system crash and lose all your grades the day before they're due?
Would you rather have a field trip where every student gets lost in a giant corn maze, or a field trip where the bus breaks down in a remote wilderness?
Would you rather have your students throw a surprise party for you where all the decorations are made of glitter and glue, or have them organize a synchronized dance flash mob in your honor?
Would you rather have to write personalized, heartfelt recommendation letters for every single student, or have to create unique awards for every student that aren't just "Most Likely To..."?
Would you rather have your classroom spontaneously fill with balloons that never deflate, or have your students fill it with a thousand rubber ducks?
Would you rather have to clean out every single locker in the school, or have to organize the lost and found for the entire year?
Would you rather have your students perform a talent show where every act is surprisingly terrible, or a talent show where every act is unbelievably bizarre?
Would you rather have to read every single end-of-year reflection essay aloud to the class, or have to sing your final lesson plan to them?
Would you rather have your students fill your classroom with a giant inflatable obstacle course, or have them turn it into a giant ball pit?
Would you rather have to organize the yearbook signing session for the entire school, or have to supervise a karaoke party for all the graduating seniors?
Would you rather have your students create a parody music video of your most memorable lessons, or have them perform a full-length play based on your teaching philosophy?
Would you rather have to chaperone a post-graduation beach party where the tide keeps coming in, or a camping trip where every night is filled with spooky ghost stories?
Would you rather have your students fill your classroom with a thousand tiny origami cranes, or have them fill it with a hundred singing rubber chickens?
Would you rather have to grade all the make-up work from the entire year in one week, or have to invent a new subject for students to take for a semester?
Would you rather have your students decorate your classroom as a life-size replica of a famous movie set, or have them fill it with a hundred singing rubber ducks?
Would you rather have to organize the school's end-of-year talent show where every act involves juggling chainsaws, or a talent show where every act is performed in reverse?
Would you rather have your students create a giant mural of your face on the school wall, or have them dedicate a song to you on the morning announcements every day for a week?
Would you rather have to clean out every single supply closet in the school, or have to sort through every single lost item from the entire year?
Would you rather have your students fill your classroom with a hundred live chickens, or have them fill it with a thousand singing rubber chickens?
Would you rather have to supervise a school-wide scavenger hunt with clues that make absolutely no sense, or a "build-a-robot" competition where the robots are made of recycled cafeteria food?

So, there you have it! These Would You Rather Questions For High School Teachers are more than just silly thought experiments. They're a way to celebrate the incredible dedication, creativity, and sometimes sheer resilience that teachers bring to the classroom every single day. They remind us that teaching is a journey filled with unexpected turns, and a good sense of humor (and a tough choice!) can make all the difference.