73 Irish Would You Rather Questions

Ever played those fun games where you have to choose between two weird or tricky options? Well, Irish Would You Rather Questions are a special kind of that game, with a bit of Irish flair! They're a fantastic way to get people talking, laughing, and maybe even scratching their heads as they try to pick between two equally interesting, and sometimes very Irish, choices. Let's dive into what makes these questions so special!

What Are Irish Would You Rather Questions and Why Are They a Craic?

Irish Would You Rather Questions are, at their heart, simple prompts that present two distinct scenarios or choices, forcing you to pick one. They’re not just random questions; they often have a distinctly Irish flavor, touching on culture, history, food, superstitions, and everyday life in Ireland. Think of them as mini-storytelling challenges where you have to make a tough but fun decision. They're popular because they're engaging and can reveal a lot about a person's personality and what they value. They're also great icebreakers, helping to build connections and create shared moments of amusement. The importance of these questions lies in their ability to foster conversation and understanding, even over seemingly silly dilemmas.

They can be used in a variety of settings:
- At parties and gatherings to get guests mingling.
- During road trips to keep everyone entertained.
- As a fun way to learn more about friends or family.
- Even online in social media challenges or group chats.
The best Irish Would You Rather Questions often involve:
1. Humor and lightheartedness
2. A touch of the absurd
3. References to Irish culture (like tea, weather, or traditional music)
4. Dilemmas that are difficult to answer, making the choice more interesting.
Ultimately, these questions are designed to be a bit of fun, sparking debate and laughter without any real right or wrong answers.

Foodie Fiascos: A Taste of Irish Dilemmas

Would you rather only eat Tayto crisps for the rest of your life, or only eat Barry's Tea for the rest of your life?
Would you rather have to eat a full Irish breakfast every single day for a year, or never eat a potato again?
Would you rather have to drink a pint of Guinness every hour on the hour for 24 hours, or eat a whole block of mature cheddar cheese in one sitting?
Would you rather have to make soda bread with only buttermilk that has gone slightly off, or have to make Irish stew with only leeks instead of potatoes?
Would you rather have every meal you eat spiced with cumin, or have every drink you consume taste faintly of Marmite?
Would you rather have to eat a full Irish breakfast that is inexplicably cold, or have to eat a shepherd's pie that is overwhelmingly sweet?
Would you rather have your dessert always be bread and butter pudding, or your starter always be black pudding?
Would you rather have to eat your fish and chips with a spoon, or have to eat your ice cream with chopsticks?
Would you rather your ice cream always be mint chocolate chip, or your favourite savory dish always be a mild curry?
Would you rather have to eat a whole jar of pickled onions like sweets, or have to drink a bottle of Lucozade like it's fine wine?
Would you rather have to eat boiled cabbage for every meal, or have to eat Brussels sprouts that are still frozen for every meal?
Would you rather your only option for bread be a very dry scone, or your only option for soup be a very watery broth?
Would you rather have to eat a whole Cadbury's Dairy Milk bar with every lunch, or have to drink a full bottle of Lucozade with every dinner?
Would you rather have to eat your pizza with a knife and fork, or have to eat your pasta with your hands?
Would you rather have your chocolate always be white chocolate, or your cheese always be mild cheddar?
Would you rather have to eat your corn on the cob using only your teeth, or have to eat your peas with a ladle?
Would you rather have your only choice of dessert be rhubarb crumble, or your only choice of main course be liver and onions?
Would you rather have to eat a whole packet of Hobnobs with every cup of tea, or have to eat a whole jar of pickled walnuts with every pint?
Would you rather have your coffee always taste of aniseed, or your tea always taste of mint?
Would you rather have to eat a bowl of porridge made with seawater, or a bowl of rice pudding made with sour milk?

Weather Woes: Embracing the Irish Climate

Would you rather have to wear shorts and a t-shirt in a snowstorm, or wear a heavy winter coat and hat in the middle of a heatwave?
Would you rather it rain on your head every time you step outside for a year, or have a constant strong wind that blows your hat off every day for a year?
Would you rather have to walk everywhere in wellington boots, even on a sunny day, or have to carry an umbrella permanently, even when it's dry?
Would you rather have to swim in the Atlantic Ocean every morning before breakfast, or have to hike up a very steep hill every evening before dinner?
Would you rather always be slightly damp, or always be slightly too hot?
Would you rather have to wear a sun hat and sunglasses indoors, or a scarf and gloves when it's boiling hot?
Would you rather have to sing loudly every time a cloud passes overhead, or have to dance a jig every time the sun comes out?
Would you rather it hail on your picnic, or have a sudden downpour during your outdoor wedding?
Would you rather have to constantly wipe condensation off your windows, or constantly sweep leaves from your doorstep?
Would you rather have to wear a raincoat and wellies to a formal event, or wear a ballgown and heels to go digging for potatoes?
Would you rather have to wear a woolly jumper that's always itchy, or wear socks that are always slightly damp?
Would you rather have to shout your conversations because of the wind, or have to whisper them because of the fog?
Would you rather it always be foggy and you can only see 10 feet ahead, or it always be sleeting and you can barely see at all?
Would you rather have to live in a house with no heating in winter, or no air conditioning in summer?
Would you rather have to walk through a blizzard with only a thin jacket, or a hurricane with only an umbrella?
Would you rather it drizzle constantly, or have sudden, unexpected torrential downpours?
Would you rather have to wear a hat that's too small and keeps falling off, or a hat that's too big and covers your eyes?
Would you rather have to carry a fan with you everywhere in the winter, or a hot water bottle with you everywhere in the summer?
Would you rather have to wear a waterproof hat that's also a very bright, obnoxious colour, or a pair of waterproof gloves that make your hands sweat profusely?
Would you rather have to endure a constant cold breeze that chills you to the bone, or a relentless, humid warmth that makes you feel sticky?

Pub & Social Life Shenanigans

Would you rather have to sing a song every time you order a drink at the pub, or have to tell a joke to the bartender before they serve you?
Would you rather be able to talk to animals but only when you're drunk, or be able to predict the lottery numbers but only after the draw has happened?
Would you rather have to dance a jig on the table every time you finish your pint, or have to recite a poem to your fellow drinkers before you leave?
Would you rather have to tell a story from your life to a stranger every time you go to the toilet, or have to give a spontaneous speech about the weather every time you sit down?
Would you rather your only way to get a taxi be by singing loudly in the street, or your only way to get served in a shop be by doing a silly walk?
Would you rather have to wear a novelty hat to every social gathering for a year, or have to wear mismatched socks every day for a year?
Would you rather have to communicate using only charades for a week, or have to speak with a fake Irish accent for a month?
Would you rather your phone only make Irish jig music ringtones, or have your GPS only give directions in the form of riddles?
Would you rather have to join a traditional Irish music session every time you go to a pub, whether you play an instrument or not, or have to participate in a pub quiz every time you go out, even if you don't know any of the answers?
Would you rather have to give a standing ovation to every mediocre performance you witness, or have to boo at every good performance you witness?
Would you rather have to wear a t-shirt that says "I'm Here For The Craic" every single day, or have to wear a t-shirt that says "I'm Not From Around Here" every single day?
Would you rather have to compliment strangers' outfits every time you pass them on the street, or have to ask every stranger you meet how their day is going?
Would you rather have to always start a conversation with a proverb, or always end a conversation with a limerick?
Would you rather have to drink your tea out of a pint glass, or your beer out of a teacup?
Would you rather have to wear a hat that's too small for you to a formal dinner, or a pair of shoes that are too big for you to a wedding?
Would you rather have to join in with street performers, whether you want to or not, or have to perform yourself at impromptu gatherings?
Would you rather your only social media avatar be a leprechaun, or your only ringtone be the sound of sheep?
Would you rather have to always offer to buy the first round, no matter the cost, or have to always buy the last round, no matter how late it is?
Would you rather have to sing your apologies when you've done something wrong, or have to dance your apologies?
Would you rather have to always end a conversation with a story about a mythical creature, or always begin one with a debate about the best pub in Ireland?

Magical & Mythical Mix-ups

Would you rather be able to talk to leprechauns but they only ever complain, or be able to fly but only at the speed of a snail?
Would you rather have to protect a pot of gold from greedy people, or have to clean up the mess left behind by mischievous fairies?
Would you rather be able to understand the language of banshees but they only tell you sad news, or be able to see ghosts but they only want to play hopscotch?
Would you rather have to constantly wear a shamrock and be incredibly lucky, or wear a horseshoe and be able to ward off evil spirits?
Would you rather be able to grant one wish a week to someone else, or be able to have one wish granted for yourself each month?
Would you rather have to play music with a fairy band every full moon, or have to dance at a headless horseman's ball every Halloween?
Would you rather be able to summon rain whenever you want, or be able to make flowers bloom instantly?
Would you rather have to share your house with a friendly but very noisy brownie, or a grumpy but very helpful pixie?
Would you rather be able to find hidden treasures, but they always turn out to be made of chocolate, or be able to communicate with the wind, but it only ever whispers secrets?
Would you rather have to lead a parade of mythical creatures through your town, or have to host a tea party for a group of very polite giants?
Would you rather be able to change the colour of anything you touch, but only to shades of green, or be able to make any object levitate, but only an inch off the ground?
Would you rather have to sing a lullaby to a dragon every night, or have to knit a jumper for a snowman every winter?
Would you rather be able to understand the meaning of bird songs, but they only sing riddles, or be able to see the future, but only in blurry, unfocused images?
Would you rather have to deliver mail to fairies in another dimension, or have to collect dew drops from moonbeams?
Would you rather be able to teleport, but only to places you've never been before, or be able to become invisible, but only when you're singing opera?
Would you rather have to fight off a horde of tiny goblins with a toothpick, or charm a grumpy troll with a bad joke?
Would you rather be able to control the weather, but only to make it slightly colder, or be able to control your dreams, but they always involve being chased by a large, fluffy sheep?
Would you rather have to wear a cloak made of cobwebs, or a hat decorated with glow-worms?
Would you rather be able to understand the thoughts of trees, but they only complain about the weather, or be able to have conversations with statues, but they only tell boring historical facts?
Would you rather have to lead a herd of wild unicorns across the country, or have to teach a flock of griffins how to fly properly?

Everyday Irish Life Oddities

Would you rather have to answer the door to every salesperson, no matter what, or have to pretend you're not home every time the phone rings?
Would you rather have to name all your pets after famous Irish poets, or name all your plants after Irish counties?
Would you rather your car horn be replaced with the sound of a sheep bleating, or your doorbell be replaced with the sound of a tin whistle?
Would you rather have to do all your shopping at a store that only sells brown and beige items, or a store that only sells things with pictures of cats on them?
Would you rather have to wear your pyjamas to work every day, or have to wear a full suit of armour to bed every night?
Would you rather have to sing your apologies when you've done something wrong, or have to dance your apologies?
Would you rather your only form of transportation be a bicycle with square wheels, or a scooter that only goes backwards?
Would you rather have to address everyone you meet as "Sir" or "Madam," no matter their age or status, or have to address everyone you meet with a random Shakespearean insult?
Would you rather have to wear a t-shirt that says "Official Taste Tester of Everything I Eat" every day, or a t-shirt that says "I've Got More Stories Than You've Had Hot Dinners"?
Would you rather have to fold all your clothes in a specific, overly complicated way, or have to iron everything, even your socks?
Would you rather have to always travel with a full-sized harp, or a large tuba?
Would you rather have to greet every morning by shouting "Top o' the mornin' to ya!" to the nearest person, or end every evening by saying "Nighty night, sleep tight, don't let the bedbugs bite!" to everyone in the room?
Would you rather have to wear a hat that makes a honking sound every time you sneeze, or a pair of shoes that whistle every time you walk?
Would you rather have to describe everything you see in the form of a haiku, or have to respond to every question with a proverb?
Would you rather have to carry a small, yappy dog with you everywhere you go, or a very large, very slow turtle?
Would you rather have to communicate with your family using only interpretive dance, or only by singing opera?
Would you rather have your bed made of hay and your pillows filled with feathers, or have your bed made of moss and your pillows filled with dried seaweed?
Would you rather have to wear a sign that says "Ask me about my favourite type of cloud" to every social event, or a sign that says "I'm still looking for my lost sheep"?
Would you rather have to speak to all your appliances, and expect them to respond, or have to apologize to inanimate objects when you bump into them?
Would you rather have to wear a giant foam finger on your dominant hand all the time, or a pair of oversized novelty glasses with googly eyes?

History & Legend Lore

Would you rather have to live in a castle during a siege, or live in a small cottage during a Viking raid?
Would you rather be a knight sworn to protect a legendary artifact, or a scholar trying to decipher ancient, cryptic texts?
Would you rather have to fight a dragon with only a wooden spoon, or negotiate peace with an army of grumpy giants using only mime?
Would you rather have to join the crew of a pirate ship sailing the treacherous Irish coast, or be a monk copying ancient manuscripts in a remote monastery?
Would you rather be able to travel back in time to meet Saint Patrick, but only for one hour, or be able to witness the building of the Giant's Causeway, but only from a distance?
Would you rather have to wear armour that's perpetually rusty and uncomfortable, or a monk's habit that's always slightly too itchy?
Would you rather be able to speak with the spirits of ancient Irish kings, but they only want to talk about their laundry, or be able to understand the language of mythical beasts, but they only want to tell knock-knock jokes?
Would you rather have to lead a rebellion against an oppressive ruler, or have to discover a cure for a mysterious plague?
Would you rather have to live in a time when superstitions are believed as facts, or a time when technology is so advanced it's indistinguishable from magic?
Would you rather be cursed with a terrible singing voice but be able to wield a magical sword, or have a beautiful voice but only be able to conjure small, harmless sparks?
Would you rather have to decipher the meaning of ancient runes, or have to translate the prophecies of a wise old seer?
Would you rather have to outsmart a cunning sorcerer, or outrun a pack of mythical hounds?
Would you rather be able to command the elements, but only for small, mundane tasks (like making a gentle breeze), or be able to heal any wound, but only by singing a very embarrassing song?
Would you rather have to find the lost city of Atlantis, or discover the secret to eternal youth?
Would you rather be a bard who can inspire armies with song, or a warrior who can inspire fear with their presence?
Would you rather have to face a fearsome beast with only your wits, or with a magical, but slightly unreliable, enchanted object?
Would you rather have to live in a world where magic is commonplace but dangerous, or a world where magic is a legend whispered only in secret?
Would you rather be a skilled alchemist trying to turn lead into gold, or a skilled cartographer mapping uncharted territories?
Would you rather have to battle a mythical sea monster with a rowboat and a fishing net, or climb a treacherous mountain to retrieve a single, rare herb?
Would you rather be able to communicate with the ghosts of historical figures, but they only speak in riddles, or be able to see the future, but only as a series of bad puns?

So there you have it! A whole heap of Irish Would You Rather Questions to get you and your mates thinking, giggling, and perhaps even debating the merits of a cold full Irish versus a never-ending supply of Taytos. These questions are more than just silly choices; they're a peek into what makes us tick, and a fun way to explore different perspectives, all with a sprinkle of that unmistakable Irish charm. Now, the real question is, which one would YOU rather answer?